Some Retirees Make Decisions Based on a Tax That Doesn’t Exist

For many seniors, Social Security benefits are an important source of retirement income. That’s why it’s not a surprise that a substantial number of retirees make an important decision with the goal of avoiding a huge tax on these benefits.

The only problem is, what some retirees believe is a “tax” isn’t actually one at all.

Image source: Getty Images.

Retirees confuse the retirement earnings test with a tax

For many older Americans, working in retirement is desirable either to provide extra income or to fill time with an enjoyable career. But far too many seniors are afraid to hold a job because of something called the retirement earnings test (RET).

What the RET actually does is temporarily reduce the amount of Social Security benefits seniors receive if they claim them early and earn too much money while they are below full retirement age (FRA). But the rules entitle retirees to get compensation for that lost money in the form of higher monthly benefits later.

Unfortunately, the nonprofit Bipartisan Policy Center reports most seniors familiar with the RET believe it’s a tax on earnings above the threshold and erroneously think they’ll never get the forfeited money back. If the RET were indeed a tax, it would be an extremely costly one, imposing marginal tax rates between 33% to 50%. And since seniors don’t want to see their Social Security money disappear permanently by going to the IRS, it’s not a surprise millions forgo working or limit their earnings to below the threshold.

The sheer number of seniors who make employment decisions based on the RET is astounding, though. When the test was eliminated for workers who had already reached their full retirement age, retirees who were no longer subject to it were between 1 and 4 percentage points more likely to work, and the amount earned by those close to the applicable RET thresholds rose between 15% and 20%. Although it’s not clear if all of those workers were acting based on the erroneous belief the RET was a tax, it is apparent the test had a profound impact on their behavior.

The sad reality is, most seniors likely wouldn’t fear the RET so much if they knew how it works: When you receive your benefits and work while under full retirement age, you forfeit either $1 for each $2 earned above the threshold, or $1 for each $3 earned above it (if you’ll hit FRA at some time during the year). When you forfeit your benefits, the SSA withholds entire monthly checks. But for each month you didn’t get a check, you will no longer be subject to the monthly early filing penalty that normally reduces your standard benefit when it’s claimed ahead of FRA.

Say, for example, you received a $931 monthly benefit by claiming at 62 with a full retirement age of 66 and 8 months. If you missed out on 12 months of benefits because of earnings above the RET, your benefit would be recalculated to $996 at 66 and 8 months. If you missed out on all your benefits between 62 and FRA, your monthly benefit would be recalculated to $1,300.

Over time, the extra monthly money makes up for the income you didn’t get earlier. This is definitely not the case with a tax. And if you can earn enough to forfeit part of your benefits now, you may be better off doing so since the extra boost to your Social Security benefits could really come in handy later in life once you become too old to hold a job.

The $16,728 Social Security bonus most retirees completely overlook

If you’re like most Americans, you’re a few years (or more) behind on your retirement savings. But a handful of little-known “Social Security secrets” could help ensure a boost in your retirement income. For example: one easy trick could pay you as much as $16,728 more… each year! Once you learn how to maximize your Social Security benefits, we think you could retire confidently with the peace of mind we’re all after. Simply click here to discover how to learn more about these strategies.

The Motley Fool has a disclosure policy.